| |
POLLS AND STATISTICS
2009,
2008
[December
2009]
Poll of Indonesian Human Rights
Practices.
For over six decades, Indonesia has
acknowledged Human Rights in its
Constitutions, and as a consequence
of a number of UN Human Rights
Convention, Indonesian Government
has ratified a number of UN Human
Rights-related Conventions, namely
the Convention on elimination of
Race Discrimination 1965 in 1999,
Convention on Civil Rights and
Politics 1966 (in 2005), Convention
Economy, Social and Culture 1966
(2005), Convention on Elimination of
Discrimination Against Woman 1979
(1984), Convention Against Torture
1984 (1998), Convention on Rights of
Child 1989 (1990) and Convention on
Protection for Migrant Workers 1990
(in progress). For the level of
people’ satisfaction over the
government performances in various
area of life towards the people of
Indonesia (with 230 million
population spread into 13,000 island
with 450 different dialogues and 60
different major tribes in 33
provinces with 30 different
political parties), respondents are
posed with choices of satisfied,
unsatisfied, and abstain. The lowest
is for equality before the law with
16,1% (for satisfied), 81,6% (for
unsatisfied) and 2,3% (for abstain),
while the next lower figure is for
proper job (21,9%-77,3%-0,8%),
proper education (35,3-63,5-1,0),
proper housing (36,4-61,4-2,2),
proper health (40,0-59,2-0,8),
proper security (40,5-57,1-2,4),
adequate freedom to unite
(43,5-44,5-12,0), proper food
(45,7-53,2-1,1). However, the
Indonesian people has its reward of
satisfaction for the freedom to
express and to speak (59,5-36,6-3,9)
and the freedom of faith and
religion 79,5-18,7-1,8). In
particular questions, respondents
are posed to their current jobs,
where the figure shows
unsatisfactory of 89,6% from
unlawful termination possibilities,
84,6% for their work protection on
contractual basis, 83,5% for their
current wage and, 70,9% from
unlawful action by big corporations.
A better figure is of school
termination, where the last 5 years
remain below 5% annually
(2003/04-2004/05-2005/06-2006/07-2007/08)
for those at the elementary to high
school thanks to the government 20%
of its annual national budget
education program, except those at
university level increased
significantly from
5%-7,5%-12,5%-12,5%-18%,
respectively. The current Poll in
respond to the Human Rights Day 12
December 2009 in Indonesia, was held
a national circulation newspaper
with 814 respondents with minimum
age of 17 years, at 10 big cities on
proportional basis, shall however do
not represent the national
perception.
[November
2009]
Poll on Reformation of Law
Institutions and Law Public Officers.
The poll was held by a national
circulation newspaper earlier
November 2009, at four subjects. The
first is of the public opinion
towards the general performances of
3 Law Institutions, namely the
Police, Public Attorney and Ministry
of Justice, where public are in
general satisfied of the
task-handling performance of the
police at 32,6%, the Public Attorney
at 24,3% and Ministry of Justice at
27,2%, but more are not satisfied at
65,4%- 69,3%-62,3% and abstain
2,0%-6,4%-10,5%, respectively.
Further, public are of the opinion
toward the Police performance in
handling crimes (57,0% are
satisfied, 42,3% not satisfied, and
0,7% abstain), in drugs
extermination (66,2%, 33,2% and
0,6%), in combating terrorism
(84,2%, 14,9% and 0,9%), then in
eliminating corruption-collusion and
nepotism (26,4%, 71,0% and 2,6%),
respectively. In particular, public
also has its image toward policemen,
a significant increase and decrease
chart of 0 (very low) to 80 (good)
scale over the last 9 years from
2001 to 2009, as it shows good
images
(40-25-42-37-55-52-49-46-45-42),
bad (50-65-47-55-35-45-46-50-55),
while abstain remain stable below 10
scale, respectively. Lastly, is the
poll of public perception of a
better or worst institution
performance towards the Public
Attorney over the last 11 years
(since the reformation 1998), where
32,8% sees it is better, 14,2% says
it remain good, 22,4% says remain
bad, 24,2 for worse and 6,4%
abstain, while for the police
institution its says
43,9%-13,2%-19,6%-22,2%-1,1%,
respectively. The poll held by the
R&D of the said newspaper on 10-12
November 2009 out of 823 randomed
respondents of minimum age of 17 at
10 big cities in Indonesia, shall
however do not represent national
perception over the poll.
[September 2009]
Increase of Public Satisfaction
Level on
Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono’
Administrator Performances; The survey by Lembaga Survei Indonesia (LSI) on
18-28 July 2009, was held randomly
to 1.270 respondents all around
Indonesia. On the national security
and public order issues, only 55%
respondent gave positive response
(July 2009), as to compare to 67%
(May 2009), which may caused by the
bombing incident 17 July 2009. On
the Economics and educations issues,
there is an increase to 59% (July
2009) as to compare to 29%
(September 2008). On the war against
corruption, 84% (July 2009) are
satisfied as to compare to only 45%
(September 2007), and particular
84%. respondents agreed that the
government is capable on eradicating
corruption. In general, 85% of the
public are satisfied with SBY’s
performance as president, while only
63% satisfy with
Jusuf Kalla (JK) performances as
Vice President.
Public are satisfied with Susilo
Bambang Yudhoyono’ performance as
President of the Republic of
Indonesia.
Based on the survey conduct by Indo
Barometer, Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono
(SBY)’s performances are even better
then the performances of vice
president, Jusuf Kalla (JK) and the
parliament. In general, the public
satisfaction reaches 90.4%, while
for JK is 67%. Meanwhile, the
satisfaction for the parliament
performance on 2004-2009 periods
reaches 51.4%. Public are satisfied
with SBY’s performance on politics
and law enforcement sectors, as his
policies on these sectors considered
better then the previous
administrator. The public
satisfaction on politics policy
reach 88.9%, 88% for law
enforcement, 85.4% in social sector,
81,9% in security, 78,8% for foreign
affairs, and 76.2% for economy.
[August
2009]
Transparency Indonesia Poll
2008: Indonesian Police the Most
Corrupt Institution. The
survey held in 2008 along the
year 2008 of 3.841 respondents
(2.371 business stakeholders,
1,074 public servants and 396
public figure) at 50 cities of
33 provincial and 17 big cities
shows that, out of 1.218
interaction, 48% deals with
bribery to the police at the
amount approximately of Rp
2,273,000 each. The second most
corrupt is the office of custom.
where out of 423 interactions,
41% deals with bribe at the
amount of Rp3,272,000 each. The
third is the Immigration Office
with 353 interactions, where 34%
deals with bribe at the amount
of Rp 2,802,000 each. The court
rank to 8 out of 15 government
institution but rank the first
in the amount of bribe. where
204 interactions, 30% deals with
bribe at the amount of Rp
102,412,000 each. In the scope
of area, Yogyakarta listed the
lowest corrupt city with
Perception Corruption Index of
6,43, followed by Palangkaraya
(6,1), Banda Aceh (5,87), Jambi
(5,57) and Mataram (5,41). The
most corrupt city are Kupang
((2,97), Tegal (3,32), Manokwari
(3,39), Kendari (3,43) and
Purwokerto..
Poll on Nationalism. In its 64th independence anniversary of the
Republic of Indonesia, statehood and
patriotism remain relevant in the
Indonesia history. A national
circulation newspaper held its poll
over nationalism to 845 Indonesian
respondents age of 17 at most big
cities all over Indonesia, where it
is found that nationalism has been
increased significantly to 83,6% in
2009 as to compare to 68,1% (2008s),
65,9% (2007), 67,0% (2006), 76,5%
(2005) and 94,1% (2004).
interestingly, nationalism remain
strong be it for people living in
the most populous island of Java at
54,9% , while outside Java is a bit
stronger of 55,0%. In response to
recent various social situation in
Indonesia, respondents are aware
that solidarity remain strong
(34,1%), weaken (60,7%), tolerance
of races is still strong (50,5%) but
also weaken (42,9%), but the good
news is that tolerance of different
religion remain strong (57,1%), but
also weak (37,1%). The recent
political turbulances, economy
downturn and terror attacks however
in turn creates more social bound to
Indonesians, as the pride being
Indonesia as one nation remain
unbreakable from time to time.
[June 2009]
Corruption Survey at the Indonesian
Parliament and Judicial Insitution:
Transparency International Indonesia
(TII).
The TII Survey on behalf of Gallup
International placed both the above
Indonesian institutions as the most
corrupt Institution. The Survey was
held in between 11-20 November 2008
with 500 respondents on the age of
16 and above, where 300 of the
respondents are in Jakarta while the
rest are in Surabaya. This survey
was also held in 69 countries. The
object in this survey are political
parties, public services,
Parliament, private sector, judicial
institution, and media. Score 1 are
given to the institution without
corruption and 5 are given to the
most corrupt institution. The survey
results are: Parliament (4.4),
judicial institution (4.1),
political party and public service
(4.0), private sector (3.2), and the
last one media (2.3). The parliament
score is up 0.3 from 2007, while the
judicial institution score remain
steady.
[May 2009]
Jakarta and West Java are on the Top
List the Most Corrupted Provinces.
The research conduct by Indonesia
Corruption Watch (ICW) based on the
data from the Attorney General
Office - AGO, the Indonesian Finance
Supervisory Body- BPK, media, and
public report, in 2008 there were
275 corruption cases found in 9
provinces, with potential Rp. 18,72
billion state loss. Those nine
provinces are Jakarta, Banten, West
Java (both next to Jakarta), Central
Celebes, West Sumatra, Central Java,
East Java, West Nusa Tenggara, and
East Nusa Tenggara. The corruption
cases are mostly in the government
sector (111 cases), in
infrastructure sector (50 cases),
and education sector (36 cases).
From an institution side, the
executive is the most corrupted with
275 cases, private company (27), and
legislative (17). Actors on the
corruption cases mostly are the
executive (403 persons), legislative
body (127), and private company
(122). The biggest state loss
potential are in the banking sector
(Rp. 9.49 billion), government
sector (Rp. 2.9 billion), and
infrastructure (Rp. 1.1 billion).
The biggest state loss is Rp. 9
billion from the central bank, Rp.
8.5 billion from the executive, and
Rp. 572 billion from the state
enterprise.
[March 2009]
Government Departments Slashed
Down: A Suggestion. The suggestion
is based on the incomparable and
inefficient of state budget to its
outcome, performance and result of
the said departments, such as the
Department of Women Empowerment. The
said department is perceived as very
low and useless. In most developed
countries, there are less than 20
departments only, where in Indonesia
reached total 34 Ministries (of 21
Departments, 10 Coordinating
Ministries and 3 State Ministries).
The over capacity of departments and
ministries are also seen merely as
power consensus between political
parties and the incumbent to
maintain their existence and
political presence. As part of the
idea, the minister Government
Officer Empowerment also emphasize
to change the structure but most
importantly is to change the mindset
of the government officer from being
the 'power holder' into 'people
servant', from 'the authority' to
'take the role'.
Legal Notes: Since the power
shift of reformation in 1998, numerous attempt to
change the mindset of government
officers has been
implemented, from compulsory of
annual wealth report, taxation,
fair and transparent recruitment,
merit systems, to signing of pact of
integrity, but only small progress
been made. So far, a number
department since 2004 has been a pilot project
where success implementation has
find its result trough fair,
competitive, and transparent
recruitment at the Central Bank, Department of
Foreign
Affairs, Department
of Finance, KPK, the Judicial
Committee, and the Constitutional
Court. The said institutions has
outperformed other departments,
where the qualified, the best and the brightest
staffs are those who took the seat,
and enjoyed better salaries and
privileges, including the pride of
the right attitude to serve and to
work hard. Most importantly are
their willing to listen and to act.
[February
2009]
Department of Education to
Provide 5,500 Master Degree
Scholarship for Lecturers. The
competitive 5,500 seats are aimed at
lecturers at all universities in
Indonesia, where half of total
155,000 lecturers hold bachelor
degree only. The figure at the
department of education, those
bachelor degree lecturers 65% are at
the private universities, and 35% at
public universities. The Law of
Teacher and Lecturers 14 year 2005
stipulate that both are categorized
into professions, and to be a
qualified as lecturer, lecturers
must meet the qualification both to
pass national exam certification
(leading to professional licenses)
and a minimum qualification to hold
a master degree to teach at bachelor
degree.
[January 2009]
Rp.23.5 million per Anti Corruption Case Legal Settlement in KPK.
Chairman of the Indonesian
Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK)
stated that, the said average amount
is needed by commission to solve one
case from investigation to rulings,
each. Until today KPK has used Rp.1
Billion out of Rp.9 billion of
available fund. The information is
released to respond the General
Attorney statement, which stated
that KPK used Rp.400 million for
their operational fund, meanwhile
attorney office only used Rp.15
million. KPK so far in the year
2008, KPK finalized 70
investigations, 47 examinations, 39
prosecutions and 41 executions.
Polls: Police Bribed Frequently,
Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK)
Will Supervise Police Department.
Police Department stands in the
first place as the most-bribed
institution according Transparency
International Indonesia (TII)
polling verse. KPK Deputy Director
on Actions Division further said
that KPK will immediately enter the
domain of Police Department to
supervise it. The TII survey on 15
Government institutions has put
Police Department in the 1st
rank, which out of 1.218
respondents, 48 percent businessman
admit that they have ever bribe a
police. The Customs Office is in the
2nd place. 41 percent
from 423 respondents admit that they
have ever blackmailed by the Customs
Office. The total amount of those
blackmail money from this
institution have reaches Rp 327
million. In the next position in a
row there is Immigration Office,
Highway and Traffic Department (DLLAJR),
City Administrator, National
Defense, and PERLINDO. The most
interesting case is the Justice
Institution. Even though there are
only 30 percent from 204 respondents
admiting that they have ever
blackmailed by this institution, but
the total amount of this blackmail
money is fantastic, reaching Rp 102,
4 million. KPK gave its appreciation
for survey conducted by TII on
public service, which is line with
2009 KPK’s priority to emphasize on
the public services. KPK will
utilize the TII survey, where the
survey shows community perception on
public services.
State Funds Are Saved from
Corruption. For the last couple of years many corruption case has
been taken care by Indonesia state
legal officers, namely Indonesian
Police Office (Polri), Corruption
Eradication Commission (KPK), and
public prosecutor (AGO). In year
2004 corruption case handled by
those three legal institutes which
was in investigation level are 311
cases (Police Office), 523 cases
(Public Prosecutor) and 2 cases (KPK).
In 2005 the figure is 215, 546 and
12, respectively. The figure for
2006 was increasing, as much as 225,
588 and 26 respectively. In 2007
there is a decrease down to 155, 636
and 23 cases. While the figure until
November 2008 is 189, 850 and 47
cases. Most corruptor finally ends
up in prison including paying fines
and returning the corrupted money.
According to the latest survey, for
the last 4 years there are a lot of
state fund were saved by the amount
of Rp. 859.762.538.773 (from Polri),
Rp.8.001.138.805.489 (from the AGO)
and Rp.476.456.872.901 (from KPK).
The details of the amount of money
from those three legal institutions,
from cases which already legal
binding is as much as USD 18.000.000
(AGO) and Rp. 476.456.872.901 (KPK).
At the investigation level, state
budget which were return are Rp.
859.762.538.773 (Polri) and
Rp.2.933.978.848.169,78 (AGO). As
much as Rp.139.882.439.209 has been
return by the AGO from the
expropriation. However, the number
remain questionable, where most
people believe that KPK has done far
and much better than two other
institutions.
[December 2008]
Malaysians still Contribute High
Crime Against Humanity towards
Indonesian Domestic Workers in
Malaysia. According to the
Indonesian Consulate Offices and
Embassy in Malaysia, the data shows
that most cases occurred and
complained by Indonesian domestic
workers by their Malaysian
employers, are the unpaid salaries
by the Malaysians mostly in Kuala
Lumpur with 235 cases in 2008, where
the figure decreased than 2007 (231)
but worst in 2006 (310). In the last
three years back, the statistic
shows that other problems explained
by the Indonesian workers are that
the works are too hard, with figure
of 34 complains in 2008, 87 (2007)
and 97 (2006). Fraud by the
employers are 33 cases (2008), 51
(2007) and 56 (2006), dismissal
10-39-22, for 3 years back
respectively; no working adjustment
0-123-153, tortured by the employer
42-106-141, abandoned 8-17-14, below
age trafficked 36-19-20. The new
crimes in 2008 committed by
Malaysians also shown as, employing
them as prostitutes 22), employing
them for two mistress 11.
Poll: Public Service and Public Safety in Jakarta.
The majority of respondent stated
that compared to other public
services, security services is still
disappointing. The citizens of
Jakarta admitted extra precaution
remain needed in public places, such
as bus stop, train station, harbor
and highway. According to October
2008 statistics, crimes committed
reached 40.124 cases. The major
causes to these are the limited of
human resources availability, in
spite of life pressure socially or
economically, triggered by the
violence as shown on
television. 77% of respondent see
that, bus station is one of the
place extremely dangerous for crime,
followed by airport (85.0%),
traditional market (66.5%), highway
(49.9%), train station (40.4%),
harbor (37.1%) and house and its
surroundings (89.9%). Other polls on
public services shows significant
quality progress, where citizen
found no hassle in obtaining or
renewing their Identity Card at the
local government institutions, as to
compare to 10 years ago in 1998. The
figure shows 22 % in 2008 compared
to 40% (1998) of respondent are
compelled to utilize agents to do
so, causing them extra expenses, the
same figure applied in obtaining
driving license and car registration
(20% in 2008 to 58% in 1998). Both
quality of services also gained
positive responses for ID card from
58% compared to 29% in 1998, for
driving license, the service is 60%
better compared to 52% in 1998.
Police Officer Committed to Crime,
increased by 17%. The statistics shows the figure is
6.610 (2008) an increase of 17% from
5.436 (2007), according to the Head
of Profession Division and Security
of Police Center Station in Jakarta.
The types of crime mostly are misuse
of authority and leaving duty area
without permit. The full figure
shows that in 2007, violations
committed are by 4 high rank police
officers, 147 senior police
officers, 561 junior police
officers, 4.648 second year officer,
33 freshmen and 48 government
officials. Compared to 2008, the
figures are 122, 610, 5.767, 41 and
25, respectively. On a provincial
basis, the big 5 rank for violations
in 2007 are North Sumatra, East
Java, West Java, Lampung and South
East of Sulawesi. For the year 2008
are West Java, Middle Java,
Jogjakarta, East Java, and South
Sulawesi. Besides discipline
violation, the variants includes
late for office, and uniform
tidiness, where the figure in are
12.776 cases (2007) and 39.751 cases
(2008).
[November 2008]
Poll: Mapping Out-New Voters. The presidential and legislative election 2009 is ripe,
as shown by positive response by new
voters, where it appears most of
86.4% will vote. However, a decrease
of 5% is shown by age 22-29 years
and 30-40 group of age. A worst
figure of 79,3% are also shown by
the group of age more than 41 years
old. From all group of ages, only
1.5% of respondent knew almost all
existed political parties, this is
mainly because of poor socialization
by new parties. The main reasons to
vote by the new voters are mapped
as: fulfilling their obligation as
an citizen (67.4%), winning one of
the political party (11.8%), a new
experience (9%), just for fun
(0.9%), etc. If the legislative
election is held today, as much as
33.9% new voters are not yet decided
which political party they shall
choose. Furthermore, as much as 49%
of respondents of new voter will
choose big parties such as Golkar
Party, Democrat Party, PDIP, and PKS.
New voters are easily influenced by
sort of interests such as parents,
friends, relative, neighbors, mass
media (60-67%), poster or brochure
and internet (0.5-2%). According to
respondents, programs that needs to
be developed to attract them, are
more on education and health
(30.8%), prosperity (21.3%), and
economy issues (13.1%).
[October 2008]
Poll of
48 Months of SBY Administration.
The Poll was held by a national
circulation newspaper in mid
October, where the President of
Indonesia, Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono
administration image remain high at
65% compared to 47,8% in his 45
months administration. The
indicators are as viewed by its 67%
respondents’ satisfactory, such as
in economy increased significantly
from 31.1% Iin 45 months) to 46,8%
(in 48 months), social welfare
increased from 42,6% to 55,5%,
politics increased to 57,3%, law
enforcement remain stable at 49%.
Decrease are of politics and
security down from 57,3% to 39,7% in
spite of the increase of SBY’s
popularity to 81,4%, where
respondents perceived his
administration image remain
excellent. At least half of the
respondents of 54,5% are in favor to re-elect Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono for next
term President of Indonesia, if the
election is held today.
[August 2008]
Poll:
KPK Performance for Corruption Extermination The poll published
by a national circulation newspaper was held by an NGO - the Indonesian
Corruption Watch-ICW. According to ICW, the first 5 years (2002-2007) 59
persons were brought to the anti corruption court from various
professions, such as senior government officers (22 persons), member of
the Commissions and Secretary General (12), businessmen (10),
Governors/Majors (5), staffs of the Supreme Court (5), ex-Ministers (2),
lawyers (2) and public attorneys (1). On the amount of state
loss-handled, 30 cases involving state loss of Rp1billion to Rp20
billion, null/void loss (20 cases), over Rp100 billion loss (5 cases),
Rp61 billion to 80 billion loss (3 cases) and Rp21 billion to Rp40
billion loss (2 cases). On a sectoral basis (December 2007 to Juli
2008), the government officer or the executive are at the most corrupt
(6 persons), followed by the legislative (6), private entities (4),
banking (3), state enterprises/state commissions/public attorney (each
1). The government has also provided at least 6 laws since 1999, to
fully support KPK moves, including the right to eavesdrop/ tapping phone
lines of a suspect. Also recently, the KPK has publicly announced a new
uniform for a corruption suspect during trials/sessions.
Poll: Foreign Investors
Control Over Indonesia Economy.
The poll held by Setara Institute of
800 respondents age of 17 to 22 in
May 2008 shows, that 60,8 percent
believe that foreign investors took
control the Indonesian economy. The
young generation suggested that
Indonesia as a nation must take over
the control as President Evo Morales
of Bolivia did to his country
particularly in oil mining. The poll
also shows low expectation of 57
percent domestic capability to
compete with foreign entrepreneurs,
and of 50,7 percent did not agree
privatization of potential state
enterprises. 56,85 percent
respondents also perceive there is
an economy draw back in the last 10
years, proven by 76 percent sees
development are not for the poor and
60,9 percent believe developments
are not in concordance to the
Indonesia Constitution in protecting
main natural resources and entities
for the people' prosperity. In
foreign investment, however, an
Indonesian economist Chatib Basri
from the University of Indonesia
argued, that the survey did not meet
the review issued by a number of
international organization, OECD,
IFC, and the world bank who
considered Indonesia as a close
country for foreign investors due to
its updated Investment Law and
negative list, ranked Indonesia at
135 out of 170 in open economy
index.
[June 2008]
Poll on Indonesian Police Performance. Following the police
overreaction, low performance and unprofessional conduct towards
students demonstration at a university in Indonesia causing one student
death as a result of police' abuse recently, an Indonesian national
circulation newspaper held its poll. The public opinion (61,3%) are in
the above opinion in general. In particular, the public perception are
very low towards police performance in solving crime (57,5%-unsatisfied,
42,2%-satisfied , and 0,2%-abstain), handling terrorism
(52,1%-46%-1,9%), handling corruption (74,8%-24,5%-0,7%), Human Rights
Violation (74,3%-23,3%-2,4%), cases involving government officers or
member of the police (76,9%-21,2%-1,9%), traffic violation
(61,5%-37,3%-1,2%), traffic jams (58,4%-41,0%-0,6%). The public only
slightly perceive police are capable at handling traffic accident
(46,7%-50,71,6%). On the image, the public perceive policemen are bad in
reputation (50,6%) against good reputation (46,7%) and abstain (2,7%) in
year 2008, a significant reduce from year 2005 (37,2%-55,2% and 9,8%).
Year 2005 is the lowest reaching 57,8%.
Poll on President SBY Popularity. The poll held by IndoBarometer
at 33 major cities in Indonesia with 1200 respondents, shows that people
now are more in favour for Megawati Soekarnoputri as president if
the presidential election is held today (26,1%) rather than President
Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono (19,1%). The poll also shows that Susilo' are
less favourable for the second term 2009-2014 (50,6% against 31,3%). the
major cause for being infavour is the policy to increase oil prices last
May 2008, where previously in June 2007 people have more confident
toward Susilo (49,5% against not in favor 33,3%). In respond to the next
election in June 2009, people has 10 president candidates (from top to
low) Megawati (30,4%), Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono (20,7%), Wiranto (9,3%),
Sultan Hamengkubuwono (8,8%), Abudrrahman wahid (6,0%), Hidayat Nur
Wahid (4,9%), Amien Rasi (4,3%), Prabowo Subianto (1,8%), Sutiyoso
(1,3%0 and Yusuf Kalla (1,1%). Of the first three top candidates, it
seems that the Indonesian People' choice remain have faith candidates
from the army.
[May 2008]
Poll 10 years of Reformation. Another national circulation
news papers in Indonesia held its poll by 871 respondents from 6-7 May
2008, shows that generally 75% of respondents shows their great concern
over the economy slow down since Reformation 1998. It is the government
they blame to cut subsidies for foods, wheat flour, sugar, corn, fish in
1998, and soon to cut subsidy for premium and kerosene. Welfare State in
terms of feeding people, lost its meanings when the government fails to
secure its people from hunger and unemployment as shown by 50,5%
respondents, while 19,7% are for legal supremacy failure and 16,5% for
social and welfare failure. Nevertheless, still big numbers of
respondents thank reformation for its freedom of speech and to unite.
Further, 10 year Reformation 1998 shows positive responses for better
security and politics (35,1%), law enforcement (17,7%), social and
public access (14,5%), and economy (4,1%). Failure of reformation also
shown, where government fails in economy (50,5%), law enforcement
(19,7%), social and welfare (16,5%), politics and security (5,4%) and in
general (2,1%). Generally respondents find pessimism for a better
Indonesia in 5 years ahead (53,6%) pinpointing the unclear of national
future plan (66,8%). The 4 amendment of the constitution and the
strengthening of public institutions are merely normative, where
politicians remain unaware to put great concern over the people.
Regional autonomy
brought local politics competition, instead of independency and growth
for the people.
[April 2008]
Poll of 10 year of Reformation. The poll
held by demos, a research institute in human rights and
democracy, shows a fundamental change reduce from 74% in
2004 to 66% in 2007 for freedom to embrace religion,
language and culture, also a significant reduce from 74%
in 2004 to 60% in 2006 for freedom of speech, to unite
and to engage into an organization. This is as a result
that democracy in Indonesia are viewed in various form,
different paradigm of democracy by the people, and also
that democracy find it obstacle from economy policies in
terms of globalization. Therefore, a new rigid and solid
policy in law and government must win over economy
policy. However, significant progress is clearly shown
by the actions towards new laws and regulations,
significant corruption extermination, less abuse of
powers by government officials, and the obedience of law
by government officials and public officials.
Poll on Government
Legal Officers. The poll held earlier in March 2008 by
867 respondents at 13 major cities in Indonesia shows
public disappointment towards legal officers performance
these days, where 73,2% perceive no public service are
free from corruption by its officers, legal officers in
particular. The General Attorney’s Office and Police
Institution was receive 95,4% and 73,4% of distrust,
respectively. Indonesian Anti Corruption (KPK) also
receive 73,4%, following the arrest of its member (a
police retiree) for a graft and blackmailing during a
corruption investigation by a state enterprise, last
February 2008. Again it is the General Attorney Office
and Police Institution were those who did not commit to
corruption extermination by 84,7% and 81,2%
respectively, including the Supreme Court (75,3%), the
Court (82,2%), and KPK (67,2%). Almost half respondents
(55,2%) do not trust the commitment to combat corruption
in general in contrary to 42,7% who remain in trust. Of
the image, General Attorneys good image increase from
29,3% up from 22,3% last year the same period. Even
worse, 74,4% respondents distrust the court. It is now
the public compel the renewal of new tougher bill of
anti corruption, since they perceive the current laws
and regulation is good since its inception in 1998, but
did not sufficiently implemented. A new credible and
accountable legal officer is a must.
Poll on
Member of the Parliament. The polls, generally shows significant
perception, where 822 respondents (over 17 years of age at 10 big
cities) low trust is shown for member' appearance during sessions (24%
trust compared to 70,4% distrust), too much travel abroad than being at
office (74,2% agree to 22,9% disagree), do not aware for people'
criticism (69,2% to 27,4%) and always request additional facilities
(agree 75,9%-disagree 22,4%).
[January 2008]
39 months of Susilo BY Administration: Decrease of Economy Confidence.
The Poll held by a national circulation newspaper on 15-17 January 2008
with 1356 respondents at the age of minimum 17 years at 33 Major
Provincial Cities, shows that people are less confident on the
government ability to resolve economy downturn. In economy, the poll
shows significant decrease of confidence from 77,5% (July 2005) to 64,2%
(October 2005) to 49,9% (January 2008). Public dissatisfaction on
government control of the hike of prices, increased from 76% (November
2007) to 82% (January 2008). International price hikes of rice, fuel,
and kerosene, directly affected the increase of food prices where most
people are affected, causing increase of poor people from 35,10 millions
(early 2006) to 39,5% (January 2008). These affects SBY administration
image decrease from 74,9% (November 2007) to 74,6% (January 2008).
|
|
|
|
| |
| |
2007, 2006, 2005:
[December 2007]
Indonesian
Police is the Most Corrupt Institution. Following the findings
by the International Human Rights Commission (IHRC), where the
Indonesian Police Institution is on top of human rights violation, now
the International Transparency (TI) has its another findings. The score
for Indonesia police is the highest of 4,2, compared to the Indonesian
parliament and judicial body and political parties (4,1 and 4,0
respectively). The key finding factors in Indonesia in 3 years in
row 2005-2007, found the scores are
4,0-4,2-4,2 (police), 4,0-4,2-4,1 (parliament and judiciary) and
4,2-4,1-4,0 (political parties). The identified problems is of
perception, where most people think corruption is defined only for state
loss, far from the legal definition covering also bribe, authority
misconduct, gifts, a promise to give, and others under the Indonesian
Corruption Law. In respect to the corruption extermination by 6
independent and government institutions, the Indonesian Vice President
Jusuf Kalla recently also shows his confusion of how confident Indonesia
corruptors these days until found guilty by the court and imprisoned.
The poll held in Indonesia with 1,010 respondents in big cities in
Indonesia , out of 63,199 respondents at 60 countries held by TI.
[November 2007]
The Role
of
ASEAN
in the Eye of Indonesians.
The signing of ASEAN Charter on the 13th
ASEAN Summit conference in Singapore on 20 November
2007, become a milestone of ASEAN for a new beginning of
the establishment of a better-managed organization.
ASEAN charter will serve as a guidance of interest by
ASEAN member countries though the poll shows low
expectation of the ability of ASEAN to materialize the
Charter. Respondents also perceive a pessimistic
attitude over the ability of ASEAN to support a clean
government of member countries (69.4%) and to ensure to
uphold the law (53.6%). The majority (as mush as 78.3%)
are confident that social and culture sector is more
likely to be materialized. Positives appreciation is
shown by 76.2% respondents in the ASEAN' ability to
support the security in the south east region.
Meanwhile, 69.9% respondents are optimistic the ability
of ASEAN to establish an ASEAN economic community (AEC)
2015. More than 47.2% in contrary to 48,5% of
respondents think that ASEAN has yet not succeeded in
showing their role to make the region a new economic
power. The role of ASEAN in supporting democratization
process is also negative, Myanmar issue in particular,
where 38.5% perceive ASEAN plays a minimum part in the
dispute. 58.3% believed ASEAN also plays a minimum role
in dealing with disputes borders. 62.7% respondents
stated that ASEAN as an organization doesn’t give much
help in combating women and child trafficking in the
region.
The
recent
poll was held by
an Indonesian national circulation newspapers with 839
respondents over 17 years old in 10 big cities in
Indonesia.
Poll on Military Service. The Indonesian Department of
Defense' plan to introduce new law on civil service under the strategic
component reserve attract positive responses of 69,5% support by
respondents at 10 big cities in Indoneisa, recently. Respondents grounds
are their full awareness on potential threat toward Indonesia as a
nation, which is remain high (58,6%), threat from its neighbor in
particular (60%). Though 65% relied the national defense on Indonesia
military, in turn they are doubtful on the quality of war machines
(59,6%) and its personnel (55%). An optimistic figure of 42,9% civilians
are ready to join the service, though 50,2% are not. Interestingly,
Papua (31,6%) rank the highest in percentage to join when civil
mobilization is required in the event of state defense of emergency,
followed by Surabaya, Jakarta, Makassar and Padang (14,5%, 13,2%, 12,5%
and 11,5% respectively). Indonesian military and police are those on top
to support the new law (85,7%), followed by government officers (77,4%),
private individuals and businessmen (each 69,8%) and students (66,4%).
The poll was held by a national circulation newspaper with 850
respondents at 10 major cities in Indonesia.
[October 2007]
World
Food Day, 16 October 2007. The event reminds Indonesians that
since 1998, following the 1994 WTO trade liberalization, Indonesia turn
to be a net importer of foods as a result of import surges, such as beef
(85% import surge in 2000), rice (84% in 1998), corn (72% in 2000), and
sugar (50% in 1999) and chicken (121% import surge in 1999). The volume
of import for 10 food products in 1996-2005 shows significant increase
reaching USD 1.6 billion, annually. These are as a result of
agricultural subsidies by developed countries to its farmer, such as 80%
by OECD, protection at 34% by the European Union, South Korea (73%),
Norway (66%), Japan (64%). Protection and subsidies are the keywords for
developed countries to maintain transnational companies - TNC control
over the world's food supply. Products protected varied from rice
(5.43), sugar (2.04) and milk (1.85). It means, the price are dumped, an
unfair trade practices under the WTO rules. TNCs took control of 16 food
products around the world, a limited type of wheat, rice, corn and nuts,
instead of maintaining other foods grows in a number of developing
countries.
Cartel
Identified on Indonesian Drugs Industries. A new presidential
regulation drafted to allow the government and judicial officers to
proceed the business and exterminate the cartel and drugs businesses.
Minister of Health Siti Fadillah Supari also stresses out that, the
findings by a number of research institutes shows, the current drugs
businesses created high price of drugs reaching 5 to 200% from the
original price distorted by at least 8 points of distributions
(factories, wholesalers, retailers, selling point, outlets, and
consumers). The cartel involves 5 major drug factories, 200 small and
medium size drugs factories, 1,500 distributors, 6,500 pharmacies, 3,000
drug stores, thousands of hospitals and clinics. The enormous profit hit
the consumers badly, the poor in particular. The results to avail them
to buy, the research also shows that 77% out of 257 respondents buy
imitated drugs, where such 40% imitated drug are supplied at 600 drug
stores.
[August 2007]
Poll of the Member of the Parliament' Performance. The
poll held in commemorating its 62 years of its rule in the
Indonesian lawmaking and politics. Since reformation 1998, the
parliament have undergone significant changes, where member are
more educated, younger, and with various background of
professions. The Parliament also empowered to take over the
control for lawmaking (77 new laws since 2004 for the member for
the period of 2004-2009). However, 78% (or 60 laws) of such laws
are under the initiative of the government instead by the member
of parliament. Respondents perceive that the law qualities
degrade since a number of laws (law 22/2004, 27/2004, 32/2004)
wholly annulled by the Constitution Court, with argument the
laws are in contrary to the constitution. Respondents also are
in view that parliament members are less able to control the
government (76,3%), less able to well-function (65,6%), less
able to respond to public needs (66,7%), less able to be the
forefront for national politic accelerator (64%), less able to
uphold human rights issues (71,5%), and only aware of its own
politic party representation (66,9%). In spite of the above,
member of parliaments' images are negative, since they always
being absent for hearings (70,4%), late to attend hearings
(68,4%), too many trips abroad (74,2%), critism-prove (69,2%).
In general, the positive image remain below 30% since they took
the seat in 2001. The poll by 822 -
1.379 respondents shall however, do not represent general
national perceptions.
Judges and public Attorneys at the lowest for Obedience Rate.
This is in relation to the compulsory report of their personal wealth
according to the Indonesian Corruption Extermination Body - KPK, where
judges and public attorneys are those the lowest (only 43,77% out of
20.991 staffs) after the government officers, member of the parliament
and state enterprises executives, where the statistic obedience rate are
67,564% (out of 61.809 staffs), 70,06% (out of 23.78 staffs) and 73,09%
(out of 7413 staffs), respectively.
[July 2007]
Foreign Investment Increased at 18.21%The above figure
from the Indonesian Coordination Board of Investment (BKPM) is for the
January-May 2007 period, which reached USD 3,7 billion of 401 projects.
In 2006 it reached only USD 3,13 billion of 377 projects, respectively.
In 2007 BKPM expects the investment will reach USD 19,79 billion.
[June 2007]
Indonesia - Japan Finalized Economic Partnership Agreement
(EPA). The Discussion Record was signed in Tokyo on 22
June 2007, official agreement is expected to be signed in August
by both Presidents. Indonesia will play the role for production
centre not only for Japan market, but also the region through
establishment of Manufacturing Industrial Development Center for
the component manufacturing for automotive, electronic and
engines to meet Japan' standards. Zero percent tariffs applied
to 91% of Indonesian export to Japan, where in turn Indonesia
reduce them at 30%. In labor issues, internship of 3-4 years in
Japan will be open for hospitality industries. The trade between
Japan-Indonesia in 2006 reached USD 12,2 billion for oil & gas
to Japan, where in turn USD5,4 billion for non-oil and gas to
Indonesia.
[May 2007]
Poll on 9 years
of Reformation in Indonesia. The poll held by a national
circulation newspapers by 875 respondents in 10 big cities in Indonesia,
shows that, generally people are not satisfied with the government’s
achievement in economy (81,3%), social welfare (77,4%), but less in law
(73,7%) and politics/security (69,9%). Answers to the questions in
various issues also shows high degree in unsatisfactory results, where
people still believe Soeharto’s influence in national politics (87,4%),
unsolved corruption by conglomerates (82,7%), May 1998 case trials
(90,1%), and high living cost - particularly after the oil increase in
2005 (93,1%). Generally, people also felt that increase price for living
are getting worst (57,4%) and people have less access to jobs and
businesses (50,2%). These are in contrast to good result of satisfactory
in freedom of expressions (49%) and freedom in politics (49,3%). Of the
six agenda of reformation, only one not yet achieved, that is the trial
of the Soeharto Families for corruption, though most are satisfied in
the other 5 agenda of the supremacy of law, KKN extermination, amendment
of constitution, regional autonomy and the civil supremacy.
[April 2007]
Poverty Reduced. According to the government official
report, the number decreased from 19,14 % (in 2000) to 15,9 % (in 2005)
for total population of 225 millions. However, as a respond to the high
increase of gas and oil price in the end of 2005, the percentage reached
17,75%. State' budget to reduce poverty has been significantly increased
from Rp18 trillion (USD 2 billion) in 2004 to Rp51 trillion (USD
5,5billion) in 2005 and projected at USD 65,5 trillion (USD 6,5 billion)
in 2008. 3 Indonesian economists and university lectuteres pointed out 5
sectors with 0-10 score (0 for worst), in what the government has done,
which are, that in providing and distribution of food reached 4-4-5
score, in providing access to education (6-7-6), health care for the
people (6-7-4), to tackle poverty (4-4-4) and to handle unemployment
(6-4-4). In doing so, the Indonesian President, Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono
who obtained his doctoral degree in agriculture from a reputable Bogor
Insitute of Agriculture in Indonesia, has his strategy for the next 10
to 20 years, so called the Triple Track Strategy: progrowth, projob and
propoor.
Indonesian Law Student Won the First Rank of Phillip Jessup
International Moot Court Competition. Held by the International
Student's Association of the American International Law Community in
Washington, USA, the said Indonesian woman of 20 years old law student
from the Faculty of Law the University of Indonesia, won
the first rank for oralist among other 290 contestants from 95 law
schools all over the world. In 2004, again Indonesian law student won
for team category. The moot court competition is a simulation court of
the International Court of Justice. In Indonesia, most public or state
universities entry competition are very tight, with seat to competitors
ratio
varied at 1: 20 to 1:500.
Poll of the Presidential Advisory Insitutions. The poll
with 841 Indonesian respondents over 17 years at 10 major cities shows,
that 62%, 59,9% and 66,8% are satisfied, enthusiast and appreciate of
the establishment of Presidential Working Unit (UKP3R) in early 2006,
the Presidential 4 Staff of Advisors in mid 2006 and recently the
addition of 5 staffs of The Presidential Advisors (DPP), respectively.
Respondents rationale are based on the disappointment by the performance
failure by the current ministers mostly in agriculture/national
economic/social problems (32% to 66%), which they agree to dismiss a
number of ministers (50% to 77%), and finally that they believe the
President has the authority to do so (65,9%). Despite of the above,
respondents are also aware the increase of budget to maintain the
advisory board may increase national extra budgets. In other official
occasion, President Susilo warned leaders to avoid being arrogant,
greed, and changing attitude to serve people.
[March 2007]
Increased,
Suspicious Financial Transaction (SFT). This is monthly SFT
transactions comparisons of 2006 to 2007 as reported by the Indonesian
Financial Transaction Analysis Report Center, which monthly SFT are 290
(totaling 3.482) to 352 (11 times dialy) respectively, of which the
first two months are of 433 to 448 respectively. Since 2002, there has
been 7,489 SFT. In 2007, 448 STF has been reported by PPATK to the legal
officers for further investigations, however so far the law can only
reach bank owners or financial institution involved instead of the
customers. It is suspected the moneys are to fund a number of local
elections, to pay fines by corruptors and worst are corruptors move to
secure its assets.
Indonesia and Thailand gained 8,03 point for
Corruption Perception. The said numbers range from 0 for the
less and 10 for the worst, according to a recent research during January
to February 2007 with 1,500 respondents of foreign investors executives
at 13 cities in Southeast Asian Countries, held by PERC based in Hong
Kong. Indonesia' rank is better than 2006, and in contrary for Thailand
and the Philippines (9,40). Singapore (1,20) and Hongkong (1,87) remain
the less corrupt. However, PERC admitted that corruption perception are
closely related to transparency and freedom of speech, and that foreign
business and investors are taking advantages from the corrupted
countries and treated them as a save heaven for corruption
Indonesian Bureaucrats Fails to Perform.
A new poll result by an Indonesian national circulation newspaper with
885 respondents of at least 17 years old 10 big cities, interviewed by
phone in 28 February through 1 March 2007 shows in general that,
bureaucrat are opt to be bribed (58%), less discipline (35%), are tied
to parties (30,3%) and it took long time to deal with them (62,9%).
Respondents also unsatisfied with their services, in terms of work speed
where they tend to be slow (64,7%), ineffective (65,3%), less responsive
(64,9%), less discipline (64,6%), less able in details (62,1%) and less
hospitable (42,8%). In cities basis, respondents at 9 cities are
generally also not satisfied with bureaucrat services. In terms of its
various failure in serving the public (particularly in public
transportation accidents, recently), the respondents also in agreement
the urgency to replace the incapable persons in order to increase its
responsibility (51,6%) and performance (47,2%). In Indonesia,
particularly during the new order era, it is well known that nepotism
and bribe plays significant role in the success of recruitment of public
officers/bureaucrats.
Poll of Bribery by the Indonesian Public
Law Officers. A new poll held by Transparency International, an
NGO, shows that the court are at the top in terms to initiate for bribe
(51%),
followed by the police institution (55%) and military institution
(53%).
Interestingly, Collusion Corruption
and Nepotism (KKN) mostly also persuaded by multinational
companies and big corporations.
The polls held with 1700 respondents of business
institutions at 32 ciities in Indonesia, composed of 89% domestic
investment and 11% foreign investment companies with registered business
and tax pay numbers.
[February 2007]
Indonesian Middle Class must promote Law
Supremacy. An inauguration speech at the Gadjah Mada State University addressed by Profesor Boediono (current Coordinating minister
for Economy), warns that a sustainable democracy for Indonesia for the
next 9 years must be promoted by the Indonesian middle class. To secure
its sincere intention toward reformation, the typical of middle class
are expected those particularly who grew free from past corruption
collusion and nepotism, instead those who previously enjoyed royal
treatment and fed by social and economic priviledges prior to the 1998 reformation. The
typical of such Indonesian middle class remain small in numbers, where
it is represented by the professionals, NGO, and private entities. In
terms of Indonesia's economy these days, it is likely that law supremacy
must take place for a sustainable democracy.
Poll of Bribery by the Indonesian Public
Law Officers. A new poll held by Transparency International, an
NGO, shows that the court are at the top in terms to initiate for bribe
(51%),
followed by the police institution (55%) and military institution
(53%).
Collusion Corruption
and Nepotism (KKN) between business entities and the public institutions
happen mostly at the level of initial bid, after the bid and during
payment.
The polls held with 1700 respondents of business
institutions at 32 ciities in Indonesia, composed of 89% domestic
investment and 11% foreign investment companies with registered business
and tax pay numbers.
[January 2007]
Poll on
Government Performances. A recent poll held on public satisfaction on
the month of 27 of the Government administration performances.
Generally, the
poll shows that the performances reduced from 51,9% to 47,5% in
the last 12 months, although generally the people (72%) remain having
full trust in the-direct elected President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono. The poll also shows, that people remain satisfied for
the guarantee of freedom of speech and freedom of the press, including freedom
to embrace religion. In contrast are to satisfaction to social welfare,
economic welfare, political issues, and law reform decreased
to 34,1% from 40,0%, 30,5% from 41,7%, 59,9% from 82,2%, to 52,7% from
81%, respectively. However, the respondents realized that the problems faced are enormous,
complicated and take times to solve. Indonesia, the most democratic
country in the region, consist of 225 million of population, over 50
ethnics and 450 dialogues, 5 religions, spread over 5 big island and
other thousand small islands in three time zones.
[November 2006]
Decrease of Consumption and Tax Payment. The statistic collected
by various independent institutions shows that, there has been
significant decreases during the year 2006 (until October) compared to
2005. These are for the national consumption for consumer goods, such as
electronic goods (0.91% to 21.36% - compiled by the Data Electronics
Marketer), luxurious cars (1.350 units in 2006 compared to 3.552 in 2005
- Daimler Chrysler Indonesia), cement for housing (25,852,739 tonnes in
2006 compared to 26,772,727 tonnes in 2005 - Indonesian Cement
Association). The Jakarta Tax Office also reported the same decrease of
paid taxes around 22,3% at 5 municipals in Jakarta - the Capital City,
up to this 2006 tax year. It is expected the real values will resolve
December this year.
18.000 Indonesians composed 1/3 richest man in Singapore. Their
wealth are valued at USD 78 billions. 200 are identified to be
Indonesian corruptors and Indonesian-Chinese businessman/bank criminals.
the latter are the biggest contributors to the above numbers, such as
Liem Sioe Liong and Eka Cipta Widjaja, both Indonesian conglomerates.
Singapore adopts a tight banking policy regardless the money sources,
where money laundering is also not the concern. According to this, three
Singaporeans at Morgan Stanley, including a person awarded best
economist in Asia by the Asia Money 2003,
Andy Xie,
were 'suggested' to resign from their job right after divulging
sensitive information, where Andy Xie (of Morgan Stanley Dean Writer)
stated that, Singapore played a 'significant role' as a money launderer
for Indonesian corruptors and business criminals, especially Indonesian
Chinese. Singapore' growth are also fake and unreal because are built on
money laundering. His comments were made to respond IMF' meeting
delegates comments in September 2006, that Singapore is a success model
of globalization.
[October 2006]
9 out of 100 applicants for the Supreme
Court Judges. This is
the initial number of the candidates for the Indonesian Supreme
Court Judges after passing a number of examination by the Indonesian
Judicial Committee, where only 3 are from the career judges. The
criteria are tight, based on merit system, the qualification also
covers intellectuality, moral, clean background, deep investigation
of candidate's wealth and proprietary, and commitment to uphold the
law and justice in Indonesia. Based on the current poll, the
community perceived, that the Indonesian court and judges has fallen
to the lowest point of trust, since most judges are considered less
intellect, moral hazard, no commitment to uphold law and justice.
[September 2006]
7,038 corruptors out of total
111,000 persons imprisoned and detained.
This is the number of corruptors imprisoned and detained for corruption
cases, where those include the very recent of 4 provincial governors
(equal to state), 2 ex-ministers, a big number of people'
representatives and number of persons of high rank civil officers,
including a number of police general and army generals, which are
arrested for further investigation and interrogation, under trial and
imprisoned for corruption cases in Indonesia. 33 foreigners out of 99
are also those awaiting for capital sentences. The said numbers released
by the Minister of Law and Regulation, where numbers is believed will
escalates.
4 Indonesian Law Students Won the Foreign Minister's Award.
The moot court competition was the International Moot Court Asia Cup
2006 held in Hong Kong, where the they were awarded the Best Team,
the Best Speaker, and Third Position for the Plea Substance. The
said 4 Indonesian Law Students from the University of Indonesia,
defeated law students from the University of Hong Kong, Kyoto
University (Japan), Malaya University (Malaysia), Ateneo de Manila
University (the Philippines), National University of Singapore,
Chulalongkorn University (Thailand). Also in the period of
2005-2006, there are 18 Indonesian students won a number of gold
medals at various international science and physics olympiad
competitions, including the prestigious award of One Step to Noble,
where Indonesian represent the most from the ASEAN region.
829
respondents have their says on Indsonesian Court and Judges. The
Poll shows that 69,0% to 85,4% are not satisfied of judges performances
in various verdicts of criminal cases (69,0%), of corruption (85,4%), of
human rights (79,7%), and of criminal cases held by public officers
(82,5%) and of court mafias (80,6%). Respondents also has shown strong
believe that court mafia are at any level since case registration
(75,4%), during sessions (71,2%) and verdict (73,2%). Respondents also
in agreement, that the Supreme Court Judges must be monitored by a
separate independent entity (86,9% to 96,4%). A different Indonesian
national circulation magazines have its cover story on police
performances, where it was found that passing grade during policemen
recruitment are the lowest compared to other institution in Indonesia.
Bribe and nepotism are also a mere fact during recruitment. The poll at
10 major cities in Indonesia, shall however
do not
represent the whole majority in Indonesia.
[July 2006]
KPPU
(the Indonesian Anti Competition Commission) Report 2004-2005.
During said period, 45% incoming report to KPPU are on transparency of
public projects bidding, 10% on cartel, 10% on dominant position and 24%
for others. Sanction applies to most of private companies and bidding
committees, where both interact through corruption-collusion and
nepotism (KKN),and as a result causing state financial loss. In a recent
case of public street ligthing in Jakarta, 10 companies received
sanctions and must return public money at least Rp 1 billion (USD 1,1
million) each. KPPU identifies three models of KKN: horizontal (between
bidding participants by setting price), vertical (collusion between
participant and the committee), and a combination of both. The law for
Anti Trust and Fair Trade is Law no. 5 year 1999.
[June
2006]
Poll on Indonesian Leadership Figure. About only 26,2% of
respondents are satisfied of their current leadership in law enforcement
in comparison to 50,6% in religion, government officer (27,6%), and
member of the parliament men are the lowest (19,4%). In contrast, ex
President Soekarno remain the popular leadership figure (64%) followed
by Soeharto (54,5%) then Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono (33,3%). The above
shows people' perception in the transformation shift from past 35 years
authoritarian to present full democracy system in 8 items including
politics, economy, law, and education. In general, during present time,
77,1% believe the low commitments of national figure to fight for the
Indonesia as a nation and 66,7% remain state power to control the
national economy. The poll followed by 782 respondents over 17 years of
age in 10 major cities with 95% index of trust, shall however, do
not represent the national perception.
Indonesian Bureaucracy score at 8,2 out of scale 10. This is
slightly better than India with score 8,95, compared to Singapore (2,2)
and Hong Kong (3.1), a report released by PERC in 2005.
3,3 millions of
government officers are serving 230 millions of Indonesian people at 33
provinces and 340 regencies, which are spread into 5 major island and
others thousands islands at an area of 1,9 million square kilometers.
This is to compare to Singapore with 3 millions people.
Police Officer Performances. A recent research conducted by a
national circulation newspaper shows, that public disappointment and
dissatisfactory to police performance increased significantly 53% to 77%
in 2006 compared to 45% to 65% last year for 5 major police services.
The bad performances are, such as involving police creates bribe,
creates more problems than solving it, police protecting illegal
businesses and human rights violations. Recruitment transparencies to be
a police officers are also the main concern with regard to their
professionalism and morality , an NGO reported.
[May 2006]
59 laws released in 18 months during Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono
administration. This is to compare to previous administration of
ex President BJ Habibie (1998-1999), Abdurrahmah Wahid (1999-2001) and
Megawati Soekarnoputri (2001-2004 ) which are 66, 51 and 82 laws,
respectively. However, according to a research institute, 62% out of 193
law during 1999-2004 significantly bear more political interests than
community interests, such as additional political seats orientation.
Only 27% of laws having economic and finance interests, 8% community
interests, and 7% industrial and development orientation. The new
National Legislation Program in 2004 will integrate the legislative and
the executive initiatives in releasing new laws emphasizing on community
interest.
[April 2006]
Indonesian Constitution Supreme Court Ruling.
Again, the law 39 year 2004 article 35 paragraph (D) has been annulled
due to contrary to the Indonesian Constitution 1945 article 28 H
paragraph 2. Out of the total 7 decisions ever made, 4 laws has been
partially annulled and the other 3 has been fully annulled by the
Constitution Court.
Foreing Visitors to Indonesia, Increased.
Foreign Visitors to Indonesia 50.7% are for leisure, 33.83% for
businesses purposes. The said researches are based on the Passenger Exit
Survey (PES) in 2005 to 10.000 respondents, where most are professionals
and business managers groups. Jakarta is the most place to visit
(47,48%) following Bali (35,37%).
[January 2006]
Poll of
Public Satisfaction of the President's Performance.
The
poll of the President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono's 15 months in office
shows, that In general the public remain proud Susilo,
the direct-elected president, being the President of the Republic of
Indonesia (78,5% compared to 83,4% in his first 3 months) for his
consistency (58,9% compared to 40,3% for the ex President Megawati'
term), improvement in political and law enforcement (70%). His economic
policy is still appreciated (63,2%), though public still disagrees with
the increase of oil prices, tax paying, and rice importation. Indonesia
is the only country in the region adopting full democracy and guarantees
the people of the freedom of speech and expression, since 1998. The poll
was held by a national circulation newspaper on 16-17 January 2006 with
1,622 respondents in 31 provinces, age over 17 years with 95% accuracy.
This poll shall however, do not represent the national perceptions.
Supreme Court Distrust Poll.
The poll by 811 respondents in 10 big cities in Indonesia shows an
approval to replace new supreme judges in full (7,7 to 48,1%) and partly
(47,1 to 80,8%), judges are involved in bribe and KKN (89% IN 2006) as
to compare to 86,3% IN 2005 and finally, public unsatisfactory of the
supreme court professionalism from 54,3% to 73,2%. According to recent
bribe case by a conglomerate, 58% respondent strongly believe the
involvement in bribe by the Chairman.
[October 2005]
Poll on Court Distrusts.
Following the KPK action against bribe case in the Indonesian Supreme
Court a week ago, a recent poll held at 10 major cities in Indonesia by
a national circulation newspaper shows that 72% to 92,2% respondents
believe that Indonesian judges are prone to be bribed or involved in KKN
(Collusion-Corruption-Nepotism), between 57,75% to 84% respondents also
believe that money can buy court rulings, and 82,8% believe that a
number of lawyers/advocates at the court are involved in the bribery.
The two days poll was participated by 859 respondents, however the said
result do not represent the real opinion in the community.
[September 2005]
Poll on
Quality of Life in Indonesia.
The Indonesians perceive that equal justice has improved 11% these days
compared to December 2003, according to a recent poll held by an
Indonesian national circulation newspapers. Social relation, freedom of
speech, access to education and security remains the same. Access to get
a job, savings, and household income decreased between 5 to 11%. The
figure is based on poll 859 respondents over 17 years of age at 10 major
cities in Indonesia, and do not however represent the whole country
perception.
[May 2005]
Indonesian Constitutional Court rules 46 Judicial Review Requests.
In
general, the court sessions usually go between 2 to 8 until decision is
made within 8 months, in 2003. Out of the 48 rulings, 16 requests was
granted, 14 request unaccepted and 10 requests denied. This do not
include 252 cases dispute over election results. The Indonesian
Constitutional Court ruling was based on the authority to make judicial
reviews over a law in contrary to the constitution, dispute over
elections results and dispute over public authority, on the ground of
the Indonesian Constitution 1945.
[April 2005]
Deficit Grows.
Trade between Indonesia and China has grown significantly, where the
figure for China export to Indonesia in 2003 was USD 2,39 billion
increase to USD 3,4 billion for oil and gas and non-oil and gas
products in 2004. Indonesia suffered from loss of USD 261 million from
non-oil and gas export to China. Guangzhou contribute 40% of total
export, followed by Shanghai (30%) and Beijing (20%).
|
|
| |
Copyright©www.dahanarekan.com
2001-2010 |
|
|
|
|